[uf-discuss] microformats for normal people, like my mum
joe at andrieu.net
Wed Jun 27 17:36:08 PDT 2007
Alex Faaborg wrote[edited for chronology]:
> On Jun 27, 2007, at 4:52 PM, Thom Shannon wrote:
> > Yeah, exactly that kind of thing.
> > A lot of the power of MF reminds me of Smart Tags in Office XP,
> > maybe we could look to the way that was marketed and some
> of the UI
> > stuff it did was really good.
> > IntelliTags
> > Infolets
> > Infobits
> > Open Smart Tags? ;-)
> I'm a little wary of associating microformats too closely with Smart
> Tags or IntelliSense given the massive public outcry Microsoft
> received when they considered including the feature in IE6. There
> are obviously some very important distinctions between the two
> systems, (microformats are open and extensible, and web site
> place microformats in their pages instead of the browser injecting
> them). But these distinctions may be subtle enough to cause some
> initial confusion if the user facing name is similar.
I would suggest that uF aren't about the formating or the tagging. It's about the data.
I'm not sure I like that, but it's sort of what uF does for you. Dumb data can't be heard/seen. Dumb data stuck in HTML is almost
useless for augmenting the browsing experience or assimilating into the semantic web.
plug-ins to do smart things.
For me, the question is what does the non-developer end-user perceive when they see the "SmartData" icon? How does that relate to
their world? It isn't about the formatting or the HTML tags... Those are things that end-users don't really care about or even
When Grandma visits MovieFone.com and it has a "SmartData" icon, I think maybe it will eventually make sense that clicking on the
icon lets her add that movie to her Outlook calendar...
Note also that I would say SmartData is any POSH that is understood by the client app in a smart way. uF are the broadest library of
POSH, but certainly not the only option.
SmartText might also work.
$0.02 worth of product branding.
joe at switchbook.com
+1 (805) 705-8651
More information about the microformats-discuss