hcard-creator-issues: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(followed up on suggested tweak for Jabber only (i.e. not real world), and move out-of-hCard-scope feature requests to a rejected section) |
|||
| Line 16: | Line 16: | ||
== Suggested Tweaks and Fixes == | == Suggested Tweaks and Fixes == | ||
* There should only be a Jabber ID for instant messaging field, since [http://jabber.org Jabber]/[http://xmpp.org XMPP] is the only open standard ([http://ietf.org IETF]). It has an official [http://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc4622.txt URI]. There should be no Yahoo! Messenger nor AIM screen name field, or at least, also QQ, ICQ, MSN/Windows Live Messenger, Skype, Gadu-Gadu and the so many other closed and proprietary protocols and formats for instant messaging. | * There should only be a Jabber ID for instant messaging field, since [http://jabber.org Jabber]/[http://xmpp.org XMPP] is the only open standard ([http://ietf.org IETF]). It has an official [http://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc4622.txt URI]. There should be no Yahoo! Messenger nor AIM screen name field, or at least, also QQ, ICQ, MSN/Windows Live Messenger, Skype, Gadu-Gadu and the so many other closed and proprietary protocols and formats for instant messaging. | ||
** The reality is that there are people publishing their AIM and other such proprietary IM protocol based IDs on the Web, and thus it makes sense to make it easy to markup that existing content publishing behavior. [[User:Tantek|Tantek]] | |||
* ... | * ... | ||
== Feature Requests == | == Feature Requests == | ||
* ... | |||
== Rejected == | |||
* Nearest transport links | * Nearest transport links | ||
* Disabled access details | * Disabled access details | ||
* opening times | * opening times | ||
* facilities e.g. toilet, swimming pool | * facilities e.g. toilet, swimming pool | ||
** none of these are represented in hCard AFAIK, thus it doesn't make sense to add them to the hCard creator. If on the otherhand, if URLs demonstrating how each of these can be marked up with hCard were provided, then that might be sufficient to reconsider. | |||
== Related Pages == | == Related Pages == | ||
Revision as of 07:55, 25 November 2007
hCard creator feedback
This page is for collecting bugs, suggested fixes, and feature requests for the hCard creator
Please list your name, and indicate which version (even just a date and time helps) of the creator that you are providing feedback on. Thanks!
Bug Reports
- hcard creator fails to create a company card (no associated to a person). If just organization is entered the result is a not valid hcard. Reported by Julio Loayza, 6 Oct 2007.
- AIM screenname & YIM screenname overlap each other in Safari ver. 2.0.4 (419.3) (on the last WebKit it looks Ok, but still gap between these two labels is too small) reported by Dmitry Baranovskiy at 2006-07-20
- Build-it button is reseting the form in some version of safari
- reported by John Plumridge in email to RyanKing
Suggested Tweaks and Fixes
- There should only be a Jabber ID for instant messaging field, since Jabber/XMPP is the only open standard (IETF). It has an official URI. There should be no Yahoo! Messenger nor AIM screen name field, or at least, also QQ, ICQ, MSN/Windows Live Messenger, Skype, Gadu-Gadu and the so many other closed and proprietary protocols and formats for instant messaging.
- The reality is that there are people publishing their AIM and other such proprietary IM protocol based IDs on the Web, and thus it makes sense to make it easy to markup that existing content publishing behavior. Tantek
- ...
Feature Requests
- ...
Rejected
- Nearest transport links
- Disabled access details
- opening times
- facilities e.g. toilet, swimming pool
- none of these are represented in hCard AFAIK, thus it doesn't make sense to add them to the hCard creator. If on the otherhand, if URLs demonstrating how each of these can be marked up with hCard were provided, then that might be sufficient to reconsider.