hReview brainstorming

(Difference between revisions)

Jump to: navigation, search
Current revision (06:03, 20 March 2010) (view source)
(some cleanup, incorporate vcp and category+rel-tag for v0.4)
 
(6 intermediate revisions not shown.)
Line 1: Line 1:
-
[[http://call-shotgun.ifrance.com/view/new/puma-repli/ puma repli cat mid]] [[http://gabe95.ifrance.com/html/site-iran/ site iran]] [[http://smegmacheez.ifrance.com/content/view/alaska-fishing/ alaska fishing lodge]] [[http://joshuaw-wise.ifrance.com/img/styles/batteria-hp/ batteria hp pavilion]] [[http://lekusya.ifrance.com/library/html/beyblade/ beyblade]] [[http://call-shotgun.ifrance.com/view/new/l-uccisione/ l uccisione di baldoni]] [[http://mfirishka.ifrance.com/view/new/concorsi-architetti.htm concorsi architetti]] [[http://gabe95.ifrance.com/html/canon-eos/ canon eos 1n]] [[http://mfirishka.ifrance.com/view/new/spartito-silenzio.htm spartito silenzio d ordinanza]] [[http://gajar.ifrance.com/html/stacies-mom.htm stacies mom]] [[http://sm4.ifrance.com/lib/gf-concorrenti/ gf5 concorrenti]] [[http://lightmyfire0214.ifrance.com/topic/ideo-porno/ ideo porno gratis]] [[http://squoi-oop.ifrance.com/topic/design-software/ design software]] [[http://gabe95.ifrance.com/html/ferro-da/ ferro da stiro philips]] [[http://squoi-oop.ifrance.com/topic/cavo-advance/ cavo advance]] [[http://alishca-st.ifrance.com/text/directory/animotion.htm animotion]] [[http://dejablu503.ifrance.com/description/lib/david-gilmour.htm david gilmour in concert]] [[http://zeakk.ifrance.com/resources/articles/mai-a.htm mai a]] [[http://horcrionebay.ifrance.com/resources/articles/obiettivi-af.htm obiettivi af 80- nikon]] [[http://nokros.ifrance.com/data/anemometri/ anemometri]] [[http://smegmacheez.ifrance.com/content/view/scarlet-ribbons/ scarlet ribbons midi]] [[http://sm4.ifrance.com/lib/sexy-report/ sexy report]] [[http://lightmyfire0214.ifrance.com/topic/videoproiettore-lcd/ videoproiettore lcd]] [[http://horcrionebay.ifrance.com/resources/articles/mia-nonna.htm mia nonna poliziotto]] [[http://gabe95.ifrance.com/html/riassunto-canto/ riassunto canto 17 paradiso]] [[http://alishca-st.ifrance.com/text/directory/langreo.htm langreo]] [[http://mfirishka.ifrance.com/view/new/serge-reggiani.htm serge reggiani]] [[http://mfirishka.ifrance.com/view/new/chaplin-collection.htm chaplin collection]] [[http://mfirishka.ifrance.com/view/new/san-gimignano.htm san gimignano bed and breakfast]] [[http://atrayah.ifrance.com/topic/ddr-registered.htm ddr registered]] [[http://gabe95.ifrance.com/html/remote-zen/ remote zen]] [[http://zeakk.ifrance.com/resources/articles/dance.htm dance 2]] [[http://lightmyfire0214.ifrance.com/topic/semler/ semler]] [[http://nokros.ifrance.com/data/james-caan/ james caan]] [[http://gabe95.ifrance.com/html/lezioni-di/ lezioni di scuola guida]] [[http://alishca-st.ifrance.com/text/directory/dar-unde.htm dar unde]] [[http://gabe95.ifrance.com/html/vendita-campeggi/ vendita campeggi]] [[http://dejablu503.ifrance.com/description/lib/cantante-yugoslava.htm cantante yugoslava]] [[http://nokros.ifrance.com/data/concetto-di/ concetto di professione]] [[http://zeakk.ifrance.com/resources/articles/copytodvd.htm copytodvd]] [[http://alishca-st.ifrance.com/text/directory/kafka-la.htm kafka la metamorfosi riassunto]] [[http://zeakk.ifrance.com/resources/articles/video-de.htm video de dragostea din tea]] [[http://lekusya.ifrance.com/library/html/syncmaster-samsung/ syncmaster samsung]] [[http://sm4.ifrance.com/lib/la-gelataia/ la gelataia]] [[http://squoi-oop.ifrance.com/topic/gli-occhi/ gli occhi freddi della paura]] [[http://gajar.ifrance.com/html/sigmatek-xm.htm sigmatek xm-400 pro]] [[http://atrayah.ifrance.com/topic/nega-khan.htm nega khan]] [[http://flawedamythyst.ifrance.com/img/styles/il-complice.htm il complice segreto]] [[http://gabe95.ifrance.com/html/gocce-di/ gocce di memoria video giorgia]] [[http://flawedamythyst.ifrance.com/img/styles/ti-voglio.htm ti voglio bne]] [[http://smegmacheez.ifrance.com/content/view/lexmark/ lexmark 70]] [[http://trumanburb.ifrance.com/view/new/italiandreams-org.htm italiandreams org]] [[http://smegmacheez.ifrance.com/content/view/nickelback-see/ nickelback see you at the show]] [[http://squoi-oop.ifrance.com/topic/immagini-dragonball/ immagini dragonball porno]] [[http://trumanburb.ifrance.com/view/new/traduzioni-tedesco.htm traduzioni tedesco italiano]] [[http://zeakk.ifrance.com/resources/articles/torneo-di.htm torneo di wwe smackdown a milano]] [[http://nokros.ifrance.com/data/batteria-creative/ batteria creative]] [[http://lekusya.ifrance.com/library/html/yety-sports/ yety sports 3]] [[http://joshuaw-wise.ifrance.com/img/styles/bcl/ bcl2]] [[http://lekusya.ifrance.com/library/html/telefono-cordless/ telefono cordless siemens c200]] [[http://alishca-st.ifrance.com/text/directory/chat-non.htm chat non erotiche]] [[http://sm4.ifrance.com/lib/serena-garitta/ serena garitta lucignolo]] [[http://nokros.ifrance.com/data/hey-jude/ hey jude]] [[http://trumanburb.ifrance.com/view/new/screenplay.htm screenplay 7205]] [[http://gajar.ifrance.com/html/modena-fonderie.htm modena fonderie]] [[http://dejablu503.ifrance.com/description/lib/driver-motorola.htm driver motorola c332]] [[http://joshuaw-wise.ifrance.com/img/styles/peugeot-/ peugeot 206 xt]] [[http://smegmacheez.ifrance.com/content/view/ram/ ram 533]] [[http://nokros.ifrance.com/data/cdrw-slim/ cdrw slim]] [[http://call-shotgun.ifrance.com/view/new/televisori-plasma/ televisori plasma hd ready]] [[http://dejablu503.ifrance.com/description/lib/foto-torture.htm foto torture iraq]] [[http://sm4.ifrance.com/lib/hotel-argosy/ hotel argosy]] [[http://horcrionebay.ifrance.com/resources/articles/nikon-flash.htm nikon flash speedlight sb28]] [[http://squoi-oop.ifrance.com/topic/orlando-real/ orlando real estate]] [[http://zeakk.ifrance.com/resources/articles/cerla.htm cerla]] [[http://dejablu503.ifrance.com/description/lib/panasonic-fz.htm panasonic fz 30 fotocamera]] [[http://mfirishka.ifrance.com/view/new/il-diritto.htm il diritto positivo]] [[http://call-shotgun.ifrance.com/view/new/robot-da/ robot da cucina moulinex]] [[http://flawedamythyst.ifrance.com/img/styles/stampante-usb.htm stampante usb a3]] [[http://cocopuff66.ifrance.com/text/directory/auto-noleggio/ auto noleggio santiago de compostela]] [[http://nokros.ifrance.com/data/cover-lenny/ cover lenny kravitz baptism]] [[http://mfirishka.ifrance.com/view/new/i-simpson.htm i simpson - stagione 5]] [[http://trumanburb.ifrance.com/view/new/trust-k.htm trust 1210k]] [[http://atrayah.ifrance.com/topic/midnight-club.htm midnight club 3 dub edition]] [[http://mfirishka.ifrance.com/view/new/abbasso-tutti.htm abbasso tutti, viva noi]] [[http://mfirishka.ifrance.com/view/new/ad-quem.htm ad quem]] [[http://joshuaw-wise.ifrance.com/img/styles/foto-film/ foto film monica guerritore]] [[http://cocopuff66.ifrance.com/text/directory/bio-sam/ bio sam jako mlad]] [[http://lekusya.ifrance.com/library/html/raccoglitore/ raccoglitore]] [[http://alishca-st.ifrance.com/text/directory/seria-a.htm seria a]] [[http://flawedamythyst.ifrance.com/img/styles/bjork-libri.htm bjork libri]] [[http://lightmyfire0214.ifrance.com/topic/edgar-wallace/ edgar wallace racconta...]] [[http://call-shotgun.ifrance.com/view/new/the-night/ the night that panicked america]] [[http://nokros.ifrance.com/data/rivaz-alice/ rivaz, alice]] [[http://squoi-oop.ifrance.com/topic/c/ c60]] [[http://call-shotgun.ifrance.com/view/new/scsi-gb/ scsi 36gb]] [[http://gajar.ifrance.com/html/muta-sub.htm muta sub]] [[http://horcrionebay.ifrance.com/resources/articles/disco-radio.htm disco radio dance 2004]] [[http://horcrionebay.ifrance.com/resources/articles/modem-usb.htm modem usb isdn]] [[http://sm4.ifrance.com/lib/www-iperclub/ www iperclub it]] [[http://sm4.ifrance.com/lib/aquatrident-cpu/ aquatrident cpu water block]] [[http://cocopuff66.ifrance.com/text/directory/navigatori-satellitari/ navigatori satellitari tomtom go 300]] [[http://nokros.ifrance.com/data/stereo-usb/ stereo usb headset 250]] [[http://horcrionebay.ifrance.com/resources/articles/prova-a.htm prova a prendermi]] [[http://atrayah.ifrance.com/topic/eddie-guerrero.htm eddie guerrero t shirt]] [[http://lekusya.ifrance.com/library/html/il-colosso/ il colosso di fuoco]] [[http://squoi-oop.ifrance.com/topic/gorally/ gorally]] [[http://squoi-oop.ifrance.com/topic/www-aste/ www aste on line]] [[http://mfirishka.ifrance.com/view/new/canon-pixma.htm canon pixma ip-1500]] [[http://lightmyfire0214.ifrance.com/topic/nvidia-go/ nvidia go]] [[http://trumanburb.ifrance.com/view/new/vivavoce-per.htm vivavoce per auto nokia 6230]] [[http://lekusya.ifrance.com/library/html/donna-brasiliane/ donna brasiliane]] [[http://gabe95.ifrance.com/html/trovato-simone/ trovato simone]] [[http://atrayah.ifrance.com/topic/shinjitsu-no.htm shinjitsu no tobira]] [[http://gabe95.ifrance.com/html/anno-zero/ anno zero - guerra nello spazio]] [[http://joshuaw-wise.ifrance.com/img/styles/diario-segreto/ diario segreto]] [[http://joshuaw-wise.ifrance.com/img/styles/web-patente/ web patente quiz]] [[http://squoi-oop.ifrance.com/topic/dvd-recorder/ dvd recorder nero]] [[http://trumanburb.ifrance.com/view/new/doom-.htm doom 3 solo per windows 2000 e xp]] [[http://trumanburb.ifrance.com/view/new/dyna-blaster.htm dyna blaster]] [[http://atrayah.ifrance.com/topic/i-blues.htm i blues]] [[http://mfirishka.ifrance.com/view/new/prodotti-herbalife.htm prodotti herbalife]] [[http://nokros.ifrance.com/data/satis-faction/ satis faction mp3]] [[http://dejablu503.ifrance.com/description/lib/lg-.htm lg 7000 suoneria gratis]] [[http://joshuaw-wise.ifrance.com/img/styles/blondyneczka/ blondyneczka]] [[http://joshuaw-wise.ifrance.com/img/styles/www-cartoonx/ www cartoonx]] [[http://atrayah.ifrance.com/topic/vete-por.htm vete por donde llegaste]] [[http://joshuaw-wise.ifrance.com/img/styles/cuori-estranei/ cuori estranei]] [[http://joshuaw-wise.ifrance.com/img/styles/nannina/ nannina]] [[http://krychan.ifrance.com/content/view/yu-gi.htm yu gi oh roms]] [[http://call-shotgun.ifrance.com/view/new/alison-angel/ alison angel]] [[http://sm4.ifrance.com/lib/offerta-regali/ offerta regali cagliari]] [[http://krychan.ifrance.com/content/view/gruppi-di.htm gruppi di continuita ups]] [[http://dejablu503.ifrance.com/description/lib/couplex.htm couplex]] [[http://horcrionebay.ifrance.com/resources/articles/partecipazioni.htm partecipazioni]] [[http://mfirishka.ifrance.com/view/new/stampante-epson.htm stampante epson laser]] [[http://zeakk.ifrance.com/resources/articles/night-music.htm night music streets of madrid]] [[http://sm4.ifrance.com/lib/cop-target/ cop target. obiettivo poliziotto]] [[http://dejablu503.ifrance.com/description/lib/the-romp.htm the romp]] [[http://squoi-oop.ifrance.com/topic/progetto-teatro/ progetto teatro scuola]] [[http://zeakk.ifrance.com/resources/articles/paoa-nero.htm paoa nero]] [[http://flawedamythyst.ifrance.com/img/styles/sandra-palermo.htm sandra palermo]] [[http://sm4.ifrance.com/lib/i-will/ i will be missing you]] [[http://joshuaw-wise.ifrance.com/img/styles/uno-scugnizzo/ uno scugnizzo a new york]] [[http://sm4.ifrance.com/lib/midi-casa/ midi casa vianello]] [[http://flawedamythyst.ifrance.com/img/styles/effel.htm effel 65]] [[http://squoi-oop.ifrance.com/topic/dual-delonghi/ dual delonghi]] [[http://atrayah.ifrance.com/topic/zeljko-joksimovic.htm zeljko joksimovic dino merlin supermen]] [[http://krychan.ifrance.com/content/view/get-out.htm get out lauryn hill]] [[http://nokros.ifrance.com/data/collages/ collages]] [[http://gajar.ifrance.com/html/bent-condizionatori.htm bent condizionatori]] [[http://gabe95.ifrance.com/html/asphyx/ asphyx]] [[http://lightmyfire0214.ifrance.com/topic/titten/ titten]] [[http://smegmacheez.ifrance.com/content/view/notebook-toshiba/ notebook toshiba p30]] [[http://sm4.ifrance.com/lib/britney-playboy/ britney playboy]] [[http://nokros.ifrance.com/data/cercolavoro-it/ cercolavoro it]] [[http://joshuaw-wise.ifrance.com/img/styles/sei-la/ sei la fine del mondo]] [[http://sm4.ifrance.com/lib/midis-ha/ midis ha ash]] [[http://horcrionebay.ifrance.com/resources/articles/bigliettini-prima.htm bigliettini prima comunione]] [[http://call-shotgun.ifrance.com/view/new/fiat-punto/ fiat punto 1 serie]] [[http://gajar.ifrance.com/html/pacman-world.htm pacman world 2]] [[http://dejablu503.ifrance.com/description/lib/nomi-particolari.htm nomi particolari di persona]] [[http://smegmacheez.ifrance.com/content/view/lene-it/ lene it s your duty]] [[http://lekusya.ifrance.com/library/html/analisi-transazionale/ analisi transazionale]] [[http://squoi-oop.ifrance.com/topic/binocoli-x/ binocoli 16x50]] [[http://joshuaw-wise.ifrance.com/img/styles/paolo-pa/ paolo pa]] [[http://cocopuff66.ifrance.com/text/directory/scheda-fitness/ scheda fitness]] [[http://smegmacheez.ifrance.com/content/view/holding-out/ holding out a hero]] [[http://gajar.ifrance.com/html/luciano-camargo.htm luciano camargo]] [[http://nokros.ifrance.com/data/decapitazione-ostaggio/ decapitazione ostaggio coreano]] [[http://krychan.ifrance.com/content/view/gast.htm gast]] [[http://zeakk.ifrance.com/resources/articles/pasion-de.htm pasion de gavilanes soundtrack]] [[http://zeakk.ifrance.com/resources/articles/sigillo-segreto.htm sigillo segreto]] [[http://sm4.ifrance.com/lib/photo-sexy/ photo sexy titia]] [[http://atrayah.ifrance.com/topic/holy-virginity.htm holy virginity]] [[http://sm4.ifrance.com/lib/samsung-/ samsung 512 ddr]] [[http://squoi-oop.ifrance.com/topic/la-carovana/ la carovana del peccato]] [[http://squoi-oop.ifrance.com/topic/fascicolo-fabbricato/ fascicolo fabbricato]] [[http://cocopuff66.ifrance.com/text/directory/quanto-costa/ quanto costa un microscopio]] [[http://alishca-st.ifrance.com/text/directory/i-sing.htm i sing amore]] [[http://sm4.ifrance.com/lib/grillo-animale/ grillo animale]] [[http://joshuaw-wise.ifrance.com/img/styles/caraibi-cuba/ caraibi cuba viaggio a]] [[http://horcrionebay.ifrance.com/resources/articles/un-nuovo.htm un nuovo calcio su dreamcast]] [[http://lightmyfire0214.ifrance.com/topic/binocoli-notturni/ binocoli notturni]] [[http://smegmacheez.ifrance.com/content/view/piercing/ piercing]] [[http://horcrionebay.ifrance.com/resources/articles/volkswagen-lupo.htm volkswagen lupo 1.4 tdi]] [[http://lekusya.ifrance.com/library/html/filt-uil/ filt uil]] [[http://krychan.ifrance.com/content/view/yes-giorgio.htm yes, giorgio]] [[http://cocopuff66.ifrance.com/text/directory/torme/ torme]] [[http://krychan.ifrance.com/content/view/philips-dect.htm philips dect 215]] [[http://mfirishka.ifrance.com/view/new/case-in.htm case in affitto catania]] [[http://lekusya.ifrance.com/library/html/ebiet-g/ ebiet g ade]] [[http://mfirishka.ifrance.com/view/new/hark.htm hark]] [[http://joshuaw-wise.ifrance.com/img/styles/maseratti/ maseratti]] [[http://lekusya.ifrance.com/library/html/milan-calcio/ milan calcio a s]] [[http://smegmacheez.ifrance.com/content/view/exzes/ exzes]] [[http://sm4.ifrance.com/lib/copertura-isdn/ copertura isdn]] [[http://nokros.ifrance.com/data/filmsex/ filmsex]] [[http://sm4.ifrance.com/lib/empire-schede/ empire schede acquisizione e tv]] [[http://lekusya.ifrance.com/library/html/federica-ridolfi/ federica ridolfi sexy]] <h1> hReview brainstorming </h1>
+
<entry-title> hReview brainstorming </entry-title>
; Editor/Author: [http://tantek.com Tantek Çelik]
; Editor/Author: [http://tantek.com Tantek Çelik]
Line 5: Line 5:
This document is for capturing thoughts on improving/iterating upon [[hreview|hReview]].
This document is for capturing thoughts on improving/iterating upon [[hreview|hReview]].
 +
== hReview 0.4 thoughts ==
 +
* items of <code>type</code> <code>place</code> SHOULD use a nested [[geo]] or [[adr]] or [[hcard|hCard]] as the item itself.
 +
* items of <code>type</code> <code>url</code> MUST specify a <code>url</code> property for the item (in hReview 0.3 having "url" property for the item is only a SHOULD)
 +
* note that in the future, items of <code>type</code> <code>product</code> SHOULD use a nested [[hProduct]].
 +
* note and clarify that item <code>type</code> of "url" means the review applies to *only* the resource present at that URL, whether it is an HTML page, an image, an mp3, whatever.  Whereas item type of "website" applies to everything at that URL and contained in any subdirectories thereof.
 +
* consider deprecating the <code>version</code> property. is the <code>version</code> property needed?  currently it is optional and created invisibly by the [http://microformats.org/code/hreview/creator hReview creator]. It is not clear that it is necessary for parsing either, since all changes to hReview have been forward/backward compatible and it is our goal to continue to make compatible changes.
 +
* is the <code>type</code> property needed?  It too is created invisibly by the [http://microformats.org/code/hreview/creator hReview creator].
 +
* drop <code>self</code> from the <code>permalink</code>.  Even [[hatom|hAtom]] just uses <code>bookmark</code>, so should hReview.
 +
* should allow multiple license - switch to using [[item-license]].
 +
* item type fallback.  If the expected encapsulated microformat for a given item type (e.g. business / hCard) is not present, then fall back to parsing for item sub properties and construct an implied encapsulated microformat from those subproperties. Alternative, just take the fn, url, photo subproperties that are present as is, and don't bother to imply an hCard.
 +
* implied "fn" inside item.  if there is no "fn" then treat the entire "item" as an "fn".
 +
* if available the user shoul be able to specify a product id, such as an ISBN for books. (valid as long as no. 3 is open)
 +
 +
* incorporate {{must}} implement [[value-class-pattern]].
 +
 +
* consider adopting (for "skill" elements) category+[[rel-tag]] pattern like [[hCard]] and [[hCalendar]], don't require rel-tag.
 +
** same issue for [[hResume]], [[hReview-aggregate]], [[hListing]], [[hProduct]]
 +
** perhaps make category+rel-tag into a pattern for re-use.
-
== hReview 0.3 thoughts ==
 
 +
== archive ==
 +
=== hReview 0.3 thoughts ===
This iteration of hReview is directly in response to [[hreview-feedback]] and [[hreview-issues]].  See those documents for more details.
This iteration of hReview is directly in response to [[hreview-feedback]] and [[hreview-issues]].  See those documents for more details.
Line 28: Line 47:
* Note that scalar/rated tags would ideally use a tag space that explain the ratings for that tag.  E.g. what does Food:18/30 mean?
* Note that scalar/rated tags would ideally use a tag space that explain the ratings for that tag.  E.g. what does Food:18/30 mean?
-
 
-
== hReview 0.4 thoughts ==
 
-
 
-
* items of <code>type</code> <code>place</code> SHOULD use a nested [[geo]] or [[adr]] or [[hcard|hCard]] as the item itself.
 
-
* items of <code>type</code> <code>url</code> MUST specify a <code>url</code> property for the item (in hReview 0.3 having "url" property for the item is only a SHOULD)
 
-
* note that in the future, items of <code>type</code> <code>product</code> SHOULD use a nested [[product]] microformat.  [[hlisting|hListing]] has also shown that there may be need for a [[product]] microformat.
 
-
* note and clarify that item <code>type</code> of "url" means the review applies to *only* the resource present at that URL, whether it is an HTML page, an image, an mp3, whatever.  Whereas item type of "website" applies to everything at that URL and contained in any subdirectories thereof.
 
-
* is the <code>version</code> property needed?  currently it is optional and created invisibly by the [http://microformats.org/code/hreview/creator hReview creator]. It is not clear that it is necessary for parsing either, since all changes to hReview have been forward/backward compatible and it is our goal to continue to make compatible changes.
 
-
* is the <code>type</code> property needed?  It too is created invisibly by the [http://microformats.org/code/hreview/creator hReview creator].
 
-
* drop <code>self</code> from the <code>permalink</code>.  Even [[hatom|hAtom]] just uses <code>bookmark</code>, so should hReview.
 
-
* should allow multiple license
 
-
* item type fallback.  If the expected encapsulated microformat for a given item type (e.g. business / hCard) is not present, then fall back to parsing for item sub properties and construct an implied encapsulated microformat from those subproperties. Alternative, just take the fn, url, photo subproperties that are present as is, and don't bother to imply an hCard.
 
-
* implied "fn" inside item.  if there is no "fn" then treat the entire "item" as an "fn".
 
==Related pages==
==Related pages==
{{hreview-related-pages}}
{{hreview-related-pages}}

Current revision


Editor/Author
Tantek Çelik

This document is for capturing thoughts on improving/iterating upon hReview.

Contents

hReview 0.4 thoughts


archive

hReview 0.3 thoughts

This iteration of hReview is directly in response to hreview-feedback and hreview-issues. See those documents for more details.

Changes from hReview 0.2:

Informative improvements:


Related pages

hReview brainstorming was last modified: Saturday, March 20th, 2010

Views