rfc-2426: Difference between revisions

From Microformats Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(added other variants, An Ontology for vCards, Representing vCard Objects in RDF/XML, noted problems with those variants)
Line 9: Line 9:
== alternate references ==
== alternate references ==
Avoid linking to the informative HTML translation of rfc2426.txt, which you must explicitly do by avoiding simply using the string '''<nowiki>RFC 2426</nowiki>''' in your text, as MediaWiki appears to auto-hyperlink it to the HTML translation thus: RFC 2426.
Avoid linking to the informative HTML translation of rfc2426.txt, which you must explicitly do by avoiding simply using the string '''<nowiki>RFC 2426</nowiki>''' in your text, as MediaWiki appears to auto-hyperlink it to the HTML translation thus: RFC 2426.
== other variants ==
In addition to the 1:1 mapping of vCard properties and values into [[semantic class names]] to form [[hCard]], there have been a few other attempts to provide alternative variants to vCard.
* 2006-11-14 [http://www.w3.org/2006/vcard/ An Ontology for vCards]. Note problems:
** violations of [[principles]], in particular [[naming-principles]]
*** needless renaming / creation of new terms, e.g. "Name" for "n", "Address" for "adr", "Organization" for "org", "Location" for "geo" (that's really bad)
** introduction of new/unnecessary/flawed assertions of singular properties/subproperties. all singularity assertions in "An Ontology for vCards" must be questioned, because it has some clearly flawed ones, e.g. "A v:Name can have at most 1 v:additional-name property." - we've seen many examples where people have multiple "middle" names for example.  This is a really bad introduction/invention of a constraint not included nor even implied by vCard OR hCard.
* 2001-02-22 [http://www.w3.org/TR/vcard-rdf Representing vCard Objects in RDF/XML].  Note problems:
** violations of [[principles]], in particular [[naming-principles]]
*** needless renaming / creation of new terms. e.g. "Other" for additional-name, "Extadd" for extended-address, "Pcode" for postal-code, "Orgname" for organization-name. See "3.4 Structured Properties" section for more.


== see also ==
== see also ==

Revision as of 20:11, 4 March 2008

vCard RFC 2426

RFC 2426, "vCard MIME Directory Profile", commonly referred to as vCard, forms the basis of the hCard microformat.

When normatively referencing RFC 2426 on this wiki, either do so by linking to this page with

{{RFC2426}}

or directly to http://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2426.txt.

alternate references

Avoid linking to the informative HTML translation of rfc2426.txt, which you must explicitly do by avoiding simply using the string RFC 2426 in your text, as MediaWiki appears to auto-hyperlink it to the HTML translation thus: RFC 2426.

other variants

In addition to the 1:1 mapping of vCard properties and values into semantic class names to form hCard, there have been a few other attempts to provide alternative variants to vCard.

  • 2006-11-14 An Ontology for vCards. Note problems:
    • violations of principles, in particular naming-principles
      • needless renaming / creation of new terms, e.g. "Name" for "n", "Address" for "adr", "Organization" for "org", "Location" for "geo" (that's really bad)
    • introduction of new/unnecessary/flawed assertions of singular properties/subproperties. all singularity assertions in "An Ontology for vCards" must be questioned, because it has some clearly flawed ones, e.g. "A v:Name can have at most 1 v:additional-name property." - we've seen many examples where people have multiple "middle" names for example. This is a really bad introduction/invention of a constraint not included nor even implied by vCard OR hCard.
  • 2001-02-22 Representing vCard Objects in RDF/XML. Note problems:
    • violations of principles, in particular naming-principles
      • needless renaming / creation of new terms. e.g. "Other" for additional-name, "Extadd" for extended-address, "Pcode" for postal-code, "Orgname" for organization-name. See "3.4 Structured Properties" section for more.

see also