Microformats Wiki - User contributions [en]

xmdp-brainstorming

2008-05-09T17:38:37Z

ZachCarter: /* Follow up */ fixed broken link

= XMDP Brainstorming =

__TOC__

== Authors ==

* [http://tantek.com/log/ Tantek Çelik]
* [http://thecommunityengine.com/home Bud Gibson]

Add your name here if you make significant contributions to this page and wish to take responsibility for them.

== Introduction ==

Tantek Çelik developed [http://gmpg.org/xmdp/ XMDP] to define extensions to XHTML including rel values, class names, and <meta name> properties and values. Per the [http://gmpg.org/xmdp/description XMDP spec], a link to a microformat's XMDP in the profile attribute of head element indicates that that microformat's vocabulary is formally defined in the document. A parser could read the allowed attribute values from the linked XMDP and thus know explicitly which microformats may be in use, and which class names are meant to convey which meanings.

This page is for exploring possible additions / extensions to XMDP.

See [[xmdp-faq]] and [[xmdp-issues]] for questions and issues.

== Possible XMDP Additions ==

=== resolving when microformats may be in use ===

Currently the potential existence of microformats in a document can be declared by referencing the profile URLs for those microformats in the profile attribute of the head element of that document.

Another way would be to include the <nowiki><a rel="profile" href="XMDP URL">powered by microformat xyz</a></nowiki> within the container element for the microformat. The XMDP spec could then specify that when the <a> element is used in this way, it indicates that the microformat is used by the element containing the <a> element.

There are, however, several clear issues with this proposal:

* Not every microformat has a container element. Consider [[rel-tag]] one of the most widely used microformats.
* To some extent, using microformats adds to the cost of writing the document. It's like filling in a form just to write your thoughts. Putting <a> elements with each microformat adds unwanted links on top of that.

=== root class name identification ===

It could be quite convenient for "generic/universal" microformat parsers if they could read an XMDP profile and understand which of the defined class names were ''root'' class names for microformats, and thus be able to distinguish those object boundaries.

One simple thought would be that the ''first'' class name defined in a profile
(e.g. [[hcard-profile]]) is the root class for that microformat. Problems:
* What about an XMDP that defines multiple microformats?
* What about a microformat that defines multiple possible root class names (e.g. [[hcalendar|hCalendar]] permits "vcalendar" or "vevent", [[hatom|hAtom]] permits "hfeed" or "hentry")?

==== Another possible solution ====
<pre>
<head profile="http://www.w3.org/2006/03/hcard#vcard"></pre>

=== linking to the XMDP ===

As hinted in the note on "when microformats may be in use", there are additional methods under discussion for linking to the XMDP in addition to the current method of using the profile attribute of the head element:
* Using <nowiki><link rel="profile" href="link to XMDP"/></nowiki>. This method can be used now and will be formalized in XHTML 2.
** A problem with this method is that it (still) requires access to the head element.
* Using <nowiki><a rel="profile" href="link to XMDP">powered by microformat xyz</a></nowiki> in the body of the document.
** As noted by a number of people, this approach has the added benefit of creating a viral marketing opportunity for the microformats used. For instance, developers could add badges saying they are using microformat xyz as suggested by the example.
** Blog authoring environments allow you to insert links at will, so this squarely <abbr title="avoids">obviates</abbr> the need to access the head element.

=== includes / aggregate profiles===

Methods for including one or more values, properties, or an entire XMDP into an other XMDP as a way of creating an aggregate profile that effectively contains definitions from multiple profiles would be quite useful. They would enable documents with microformats to simply refer to a single profile URL rather than a complete space separated set of all the profile URLs of the microformats that may be in use.

=== vocabulary aliasing ===

An XMDP document could be used to define a microformat profile that is nothing more than a simple dictionary mapping between an existing, non-standard set of HTML classes and the terms in a standard microformat profile. This would allow a publisher to support a given microformat by merely using the URI of a new profile document as the value of an individual document's head/profile attribute, rather than modifying the individual class values throughout each document to conform to an existing profile. Initial suggestion with use case description in this [http://microformats.org/discuss/mail/microformats-discuss/2005-October/001623.html microformats-discuss post]. Note (from [http://microformats.org/discuss/mail/microformats-discuss/2005-October/001633.html Kevin's response]) that HTML class attributes can contain multiple values, e.g. class="post hentry", so a publisher doesn't have to discard their existing class values to use those of a microformat.

=== subclassing / ontology addition ===
One may want to introduce a new property (or value) and base it on an existing property (or value). In this sample XMDP, the value "self" is defined, based on the value "me" from XFN 1.1:

<pre>
<nowiki>
<dl class="rel">
<dt id='self'><a href="http://www.gmpg.org/xfn/11#me" rev="extends">self</a></dt>
<dd>This is a pointer to me, it extends the "me" value of XFN</dd>
</dl>
</nowiki>
</pre>
There are two interesting pieces that have been added, a URL with an anchor to another XMDP profile and a rev attribute. The rev value in
this example is 'extends'. These means that the page this is refering too, is extended by the property SELF. So you could make an XMDP that
lists all the possible rev attributes, 'extends', 'inverse', 'equivalent', etc. Then you could 'alias' one microformat property to another.

A universal XMDP validator/parser/etc could extract data across two or more XMDP profiles and potentially reason between them. This could create a small ontology.

It is not clear if this idea actually has utility or is simply a solution looking for a problem.

=== XMDP XML Schema ===
* [http://www.redantdesign.com/hcard/ XSD and XMDP for Microformats]
The link shows a bad example of creating XMDP from an XSD schema. The big question I guess is why?
Having XMDP defined in XSD should make it easier for machines to read Microformats, rules and strict data typing will allow Microformats to be validated when contained within an XML/XHTML document. If a document is using microformats with and XSD behind simple XPath queries can be used to harvest the information, this can then be rendered to straight XML for translation to RDF or other XML transport formats.

XSD behind XMDP also has distinct advantages for CMS authors, the XSD sitting behind xforms or sxforms to allow data entry into a CMS can be used to generate XMDP and valid Microformats when rendering content. This in theory should make it easier for CMS authors to develop a semantic core around data before exporting to XHTML + Microformats, RDF etc. and/or make data querying via web services a little more straightforward.

==== Follow up ====
Having looked into Microformats a little more I realise how bad that example is; however I still feel that placing a schema behind XMDP is a worthwhile exercise. I don't mind spending a little time on this if anyone feels it's a worthwhile exercise, but I'd propose the following:
* Define a loose set of microformat conventions (i.e. a meta property will be bound to an attribute etc.), and have these defined in a microformat namespace (mf:?).
* Create a XSD for common microformat fields without structures (dtStart etc.), with XSD typing and mf: rules (i.e. mf:optional-html-attribute-binding="title" or mf:html-attribute-binding="href" - names were never my strong point )
* Start working towards creating XSD schema including the common schema for agreed specifications

There would still need to be some form of link between the XMDP and the defining XSD (profile attribute or link element?). With these in place it should be possible for an application like tails, or new apps to pick up on any Microformat in a page and display the data, without the application having to be aware of the specific Microformat standard.

Microformats are cool, especially the fact that you don't have to be a rocket scientist to start using them. However if there can be a way of interleaving grassroots microformat adoption into the more complex semantic forms (RDF etc.), through XML then that's got to be a bonus?

[http://www.redantdesign.com/hcard/take2.asp more here]

== ID Attribute ==

A problem that I've had using XDMP is that it requires the use of the ID attribute (e.g. <dt id="foo">foo</dt>) to define the term "foo". As (X)HTML only allows one element with any given ID, this raises problems if you need to define the same term multiple times -- e.g. to define "category" as a class within both hcard and hcalendar, or to define "copyright" as both a class value and a rel value. [[User:TobyInk|TobyInk]] 06:26, 18 Feb 2008 (PST)

== See Also ==

[[Parsing Microformats]]

irc-people

2008-03-24T20:45:22Z

ZachCarter:

A list of [[irc|IRC]] regulars, sorted by nick, and their normal timezones (winter/summer).

* {{irc user|Amodal1| amodal1|-0500/-0600}}
* {{irc user|Adam Ballai|AdamBallai|-700/-700}}
* {{irc user|Adam Craven|AdamCraven|+0000}}
* {{irc user|Alexander Graf|AlexanderGraf|+0100}}
* {{irc user|Tomasino|aloneone|-0500}}
* {{irc user|AmanuelTewolde|Amanuel|-0500/-0400}}
* {{irc user|Amette|amette|+1000}}
* {{irc user|Amir Guindehi|AmirGuindehi|+1000}}
* {{irc user|Ajaswa|Andrew Jaswa|-0500}}
* {{irc user|AndrewDisley|AndrewDisley|+0000}}
* {{irc user|AnselHalliburton|anselxyz|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|Ashe Dryden|Ashe|-600}}
* {{irc user|Ashley|Ashley|+1000}}
* {{irc user|Azathoth|Florian Beer|+1000}}
* {{irc user|Tyler Roehmholdt|Baristo|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|BenjaminCarlyle|BenjaminCarlyle|+1000}}
* {{irc user|HenriBergius|bergie|+0200/+0300}}
* {{irc user|Ben Ward|BenWard|+0000}}
* {{irc user|BenWest|bewest|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|B.K._DeLong|bkdelong|-0500/-0400}}
* {{irc user|Robert|blueace|+0100}}
* {{irc user|BluesMoon|bluesmoon|+0530}}
* {{irc user|BobChao|BobChao|+0800}}
* {{irc user|Bob Jonkman|BobJonkman|-0500/-0400}}
* {{irc user|Boneill|boneill|+0000}}
* {{irc user|Brian|briansuda|+0000}}
* {{irc user|TimT|bringo|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|Briski|Briski|+0000}}
* {{irc user|BryanL|BryanL|-0500/-0400}}
* {{irc user|BryanRieger|Bryan Rieger|+0000}}
* {{irc user|Bug-E|Bug-E|+0200}}
* {{irc user|CarlaHufstedler|carlamagpie|-0500/-0400}}
* {{irc user|Colin_Barrett|cbarrett|-1000}}
* {{irc user|ColinDDevroe|cdevroe|-0500/-0600}}
* {{irc user|Cgriego|cgriego|-0600/-0500}}
* {{irc user|Charlvn|Charl|+0200/+0200}}
* {{irc user|CharlesRoper|charles_r|0000/+0100}}
* {{irc user|ChristopherStJohn|cks|-0600/-0500}}
* {{irc user|Cloud|Cloud|+0000}}
* {{irc user|Cruster|cruster|+0200}}
* {{irc user|Csarven|csarven|-0500/-0400}}
* {{irc user|ChrisBrentano|ctb|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|DanC|DanC|-0600/-0500}}
* {{irc user|DanielBurka|DanielBurka|-0400}}
* {{irc user|DanielJohnLewis|danieljohnlewis|0000}}
* {{irc user|DannyAyers|danja|+0100/+0200}}
* {{irc user|Dave Cardwell|davecardwell|+0000}}
* {{irc user|DavidMead|DavidMead|-0400}}
* {{irc user|DavidRussell|davidrussell|-0600/-0500}}
* {{irc user|DBounds|Darren Bounds|-0500
* {{irc user|DenisDefreyne|ddfreyne|+0100/+0200}}
* {{irc user|DeanEro|deanero|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|DeepText|Deep Text|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|DerrickPallas|DerrickPallas|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|DimitriGlazkov|dglazkov|-0600/-0500}}
* {{irc user|DiegoBudny|DiegoBudny|-unspecified-}}
* {{irc user|DKerzman|DKerzman|-0600}}
* {{irc user|Dan Kubb|dkubb|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|DrErnie|DrErnie|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|DrewMcLellan|drewinthehead|+0000/+0100}}
* {{irc user|DrewBell|droob|-0600/-0500}}
* {{irc user|DimitriosZachariadis|dzach|+0200/+0300}}
* {{irc user|DydimusTK|dydimustk|-0600}}
* {{irc user|Ed Summers|edsu|-0500/-0400}}
* {{irc user|Enric|Enric|-0800/-0700}} (alt sp "enric")
* {{irc user|Evan|evanpro|-0500}}
* {{irc user|Evan|e_s_p|-0500}}
* {{irc user|EdwardWelker|ewelker|-0500}}
* {{irc user|ChrisMessina|factoryjoe|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|Fil|Fil|+0200}}
* {{irc user|CFinke|Finke|-0700/-0600}}
* {{irc user|MarkoMrdjenovic|friedcell|+0100/+0200}}
* {{irc user|GarethR|garethr|+0000/+0100}}
* {{irc user|Grantbow|Grantbow|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|Griffin|Griffin|-0600/-0500}}
* {{irc user|Guillaume Lebleu|glebleu|-0800}}
* {{irc user|Aubergine10|Guy Fraser|+0100/+0000}}
* {{irc user|HenrichPoehls|HenrichP|+0100}}
* {{irc user|IanHickson|Hixie|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|Hlb|hlb|+0800-0700}}
* {{irc user|EdwardOConnor|hober|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|Ichigo|ichigo|+1000}}
* {{irc user|Alper|illustir|+0100}}
* {{irc user|Inkbase|inkbase|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|IwaiMasaharu|iwaim|+0900}}
* {{irc user|Izo|IZO|-unspecified-}}
* {{irc user|JamieKnight|JamieKnight|+1000/0000}}
* {{irc user|JoeGregorio|jcgregorio|-unspecified-}}
* {{irc user|WizardIsHungry|jcw9|-0500/-0400}}
* {{irc user|Adactio|Jeremy Keith|+0000}}
* {{irc user|jrodgers|JesseRodgers|-0500}}
* {{irc user|JasonK|jkridner|-0600/-0500}}
* {{irc user|JeffMcNeill|jeffmcneill|-1000}}
* {{irc user|JimboJW|jimbojw|-0600/-0500}}
* {{irc user|Jonathan_Arkell|jonnay|-0700/0600}}
* {{irc user|JosephHolsten|josephholsten|-0600/-0500}}
* {{irc user|JulianStahnke|julianstahnke|+0000}}
* {{irc user|Kapowaz|kapowaz|+0000/+0100}}
* {{irc user|Keri Henare|kerihenare|+1200}}
* [http://epeus.blogspot.com/ KevinMarks] (-0800/-0700)
* {{irc user|RyanKing|kingryan|-0800/-0700}}
** [http://theryanking.com/blog/archives/2006/04/19/office-hours/ Office hours]: Wednesday, 21:00 UTC
* {{irc user|Lachlan Hunt|Lachy|+1000/+1100}}
* {{irc user|Levitation|levitation[A]|+0200/+0300}}
* {{irc user|Linmic|linmic|+0800-0700}}
* {{irc user|MarkNg|madness|+0000/+0100}}
* {{irc user|Mark Mansour|Mark Mansour|+1100}}
* {{irc user|MarkNormanFrancis|Mark Norman Francis|+0000/+0100}}
* {{irc user|MattBowen|Matt Bowen|-0500/-0400}}
* {{irc user|MattisManzel|Mattis Manzel|+0100/+0200}}
* {{irc user|CiaranMc|McNulty|+0000/+0100}}
* [[mfbot]] - a bot which logs all edits to this wiki. It appends a number with a '+' or '-' sign, to indicate the number of characters added or removed as a result of the edit.
* {{irc user|Mike|Michael McCracken(mmc)|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|MikeKaply|mkaply|-0600/-0500}}
* {{irc user|SteveIvy|monkinetic/redmonk|-0700}}
* {{irc user|MWTE|mwte|+0000/+0100}}
* {{irc user|RobManson|nambor|+1000}}
* {{irc user|Nelix|nelix|+1000}}
* {{irc user|neuro|neuro|-unspecified-}}
* {{irc user|Niekie|niekie|+0100/+0200}}
* {{irc user|NTollervey|ntoll|+0000/+0100}}
* {{irc user|Andy Pemberton|pembertona|-0500/-0400}}
* {{irc user|Phae|Phae|+0000/+0100}}
* {{irc user|pius|Pius Uzamere|+0500}}
* {{irc user|PriitLaes|plaes|+0200/+0300}}
* {{irc user|ChrisCasciano|pnhChris|-0500/-0400}}
* {{irc user|PetarPopov|popov|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|DavidOsolkowski|qid|-0500}}
* {{irc user|RCanine|RCanine|-0500/-0400}}
* {{irc user|Remi|Remi|-0500/-0400}}
* {{irc user|ZachCarter|riah|-0500/-0400}}
* {{irc user|RobertBachmann|RobertBachmann|+0100/+0200}}
** Office hours: <s>Wednesday, 18:00-20:00 UTC</s> (Currently no office hours}}
* {{irc user|Ronnos|Ron Kok|+0000}}
* {{irc user|SarahWorsham|sazbean|-0500/-0400}}
* {{irc user|ScottNelle|snelle|-0500/-0400}}
* {{irc user|ScottRozic|gravitas|-0500/+0100}}
* {{irc user|Dana Benson|Snowden|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|Smackman|Steve Farrell|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|SpikeUK|SpikeUK|+0000/+0100}}
* {{irc user|Steve Ganz|SteveGanz|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|Stii|Stii|+0200 GMT}}
* {{irc user|ReinierZ|surial|+0100 GMT}}
* {{irc user|SuperPhly|SuperPhly|-600/-500}}
* {{irc user|SyedSRahman|syedsrahman|+0530}}
* sym[[User:LynX|lynX]] or (better) [[User:LynX|lynX]] on [http://about.psyc.eu PSYC] (+0100}}
* {{irc user|DavidLehn|taaz|-0500/-0400}}
* {{irc user|Tantek|Tantek|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|Wojciech|theanxy|+0100/+0200}}
* {{irc user|TobyInk|tobyink|+0000/+0100}}
* {{irc user|Trovster|trovster|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|Vadania|vadania|-0600/-0700}}
* {{irc user|Vant|vant|+0900}}
* {{irc user|Victor|victor|+0100/+0200}}
* {{irc user|V-I-P|V-I-P|+0100/+0200}}
* {{irc user|KrissWatt|VoodooChild|+0000/+0100}}
* {{irc user|WebOrganics|weborganics|+0100}}
* {{irc user|JacksonWilkinson|whafro|-0500/-0400}}
* {{irc user|Richard Conyard|WhiskeyM|+0000}}
* {{irc user|Veeliam|William Lawrence|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|StevenWoods|woodss|+0000 GMT}}
* {{irc user|Ianloic|yakk|-0800/-0700}}
* {{irc user|LarsStrojny|mastaYoda|+0100}}
* {{irc user|ZimbaTm|zimbatm|+0100}}
* {{irc user|FoundAtion|Foundation|-0800}}
* {{irc user|PJKix|pjkix|-0800/-700}}

User:ZachCarter

2008-03-24T20:42:04Z

ZachCarter:

Zach Carter, a student and web developer from Tampa, FL. (http://zachcarter.info)