[uf-discuss] How's my hReview?

[brian suda]

For the dtreviewed you have:
<span class="dtreviewed" title="200603">March 2006</span>

You probably need to switch that to an 'abbr' element so that the data
is being extracted from the title.

<abbr class="dtreviewed" title="200603">March 2006</abbr>

-brian

Andy Mabbett wrote:
> In message
> <21e770780608291824m5d9a08d1g330fbd1b4f51f4b9 at mail.gmail.com>, Brian
> Suda <brian.suda at gmail.com> writes
>
>   
>> It is not a valid review yet, you are missing a few things.
>>     
>
> [...]
>
>   
>> B) create an "outer div container". You have a class="photo" which is
>> another hReview property - assuming you are actually intending that to
>> be part of the hReview, that needs to be nested inside the
>> class="item" as well.
>>
>> <div class="hreview">
>> <div class="item">
>>     
>
> I suppose
>
>         <div class="hreview item">
>
> isn't allowed?
>
>   
>> There is no RATING, which is OK that is optional, but IMHO that is
>> kinda the point of a review.
>>     
>
> That's debatable. Have a look at a decent newspaper's book or theatre
> reviews.
>
>   
>> finnaly, the reviewer hCard is also incorrect:
>> <p id="credit"><span class="reviewer vcard fn">Andy Mabbett</span><br>
>> <span class="dtreviewed" title="200603">March 2006</span></p>
>>
>> you need to nest the class="fn" inside the class="vcard"
>> <p id="credit" class="reviewer vcard"><span class="fn">Andy Mabbett</span><br>
>> <span class="dtreviewed" title="200603">March 2006</span></p>
>>     
>
> Yuk. How is the latter semantically better than the former? It's just
> bloat.
>
>   
>> i hope this helps.
>>     
>
> Indeed, thank you.
>
>   
>> If you make those changes let us know and we can
>> take another pass at it and see if there are any other errors.
>>     
>
> Done, see:
>
>         http://www.westmidlandbirdclub.com/reviews/WarksBirding2005.htm
>
> Mind you, it occurs to me that, while our visitors might make use of
> hCard and hCalendar items, to add contacts and events to their address
> book or diary programmes, hReview is of less use, to them.
>