[uf-discuss] Relevant tags in hReview

[Tantek Ç elik]

Hello Vinay,

On 12/15/05 7:13 AM, "Vinay Pulim" <viny at MIT.EDU> wrote:

> Hi, I'm working on an hreview aggregator (http://kritx.com)

Very good job by the way.


> and had a question
> about how to properly handle tags.  Specifically, the Cafe Borrone example in
> the hReview wiki contains numerous reltags.  However, some of them (food,
> ambience, service, and price) don't really describe the business, but rather
> different types of ratings associated with the business.

They actually describe both, in that, the business has food, ambience,
service, and a price.


> If an hReview
> aggregator were to simply tag a review with every reltag it contained, it
> would
> contain a mix of tags describing the actual item being reviewed (coffee, jazz,
> sandwich, etc...) as well as tags describing the various ratings associated
> with it (price, ambience, etc...).

Precisely.


> Is this how reltags within hReviews were
> intended to be parsed?  That is, should rating tags show up alongside item
> tags when an hReview is displayed?

They are both in the total set of tags that apply to the item.

How you display them is up to you and the user interface that you build.


> I think the answer is "yes", but I just wanted to make sure I'm understanding
> this correctly.

Yes.

Thanks, and I have added this clarification to the hReview FAQ.

 http://microformats.org/wiki/hreview-faq

Tantek